2027 earnings sustainability questioned, JP Morgan maintains "Neutral" rating on Target Corporation (TGT.US)

date
21:00 19/11/2026
avatar
GMT Eight
Target's 3Q same-store sales rose 5.6% year over year, beating expectations, with home goods turning positive for the first time in 18 quarters; JPMorgan maintains a Neutral rating and a US$163 price target, focusing on 2027 earnings sustainability.
After Target Corporation (TGT.US) reported its fiscal 2026 third-quarter results, JP Morgan released a research note maintaining its "Neutral" rating and a price target of US$163. The bank believes the retailer delivered strong results and a solid holiday-season outlook, but that the real focus has shifted to 2027. On results, Target Corporation delivered a beat. Third-quarter same-store sales rose 5.6% year over year, above JP Morgan's 4.2% estimate and the 3.7% consensus; traffic grew 5.0% year over year, digital same-store sales rose 9.8%, and store same-store sales rose 4.6%. Net sales rose 7.1% year over year to US$27.067 billion, and earnings per share jumped 48.9% year over year to US$2.65. The category mix showed clear divergence. JP Morgan noted that Fun 101 grew about 27% year over year and still posted double-digit growth excluding trading cards; food and beverage grew about 6%, beauty grew 8%, and home same-store sales rose 1% the category's first positive turn in 18 quarters; but apparel fell 5% year over year, dragged mainly by women's wear and footwear, making it the weakest link in the results. Non-merchandise grew about 20%, driven jointly by Roundel advertising, Target Plus and Target Circle membership. Earnings quality also improved. Third-quarter gross margin expanded 230 basis points year over year to 30.5%, of which tariff refunds contributed about 110 basis points (about US$301 million); excluding refunds, gross margin still improved 120 basis points year over year. However, SG&A as a percentage of sales rose 60 basis points year over year to 21.9%, with incentive compensation the main driver. JP Morgan remains optimistic on the holiday season, noting sales growth of about 5% quarter-to-date and raising full-year guidance: net sales growth of about 6%, operating margin expansion of 165 basis points year over year, and an EPS range raised to US$10.65 to US$11.40. But JP Morgan's caution centers on 2027. First, apparel and home together account for about 30% of sales and are the pillars of the "Expect More" brand promise, yet they have yet to return to growth, and 2027 will more fully lap the traffic boost from Fun 101; second, as the high base from tariff refunds fades, EPS is expected to fall back to US$10.42 year over year; third, share competition with Amazon.com, Inc. (AMZN.US) and Walmart Inc. (WMT.US) continues to intensify. On valuation, JP Morgan's price target is based on 15x the 2028 forecast P/E, equivalent to 9x EV/EBITDA, slightly below the current roughly 16x next-fiscal-year valuation and within the historical range. Overall, JP Morgan acknowledges Target Corporation's progress in reclaiming its brand magic and improving merchandise and experience, but against a backdrop of potentially softening consumer demand, a high base and intensifying competition, it remains on the sidelines regarding 2027 sustainability and maintains its Neutral rating.