Morgan Stanley comments on Home Depot, Inc. (HD.US) Q3 results: product and M&A headwinds pressure gross margin, cuts three-year EPS forecasts.
After Home Depot reported its latest quarterly results, Morgan Stanley maintained its "Overweight" rating and US$400 price target.
Morgan Stanley North America retail analyst Simeon Gutman's team, on the day Home Depot, Inc. (HD.US) released its Q3 report, delivered a "numbers change, view unchanged" risk-reward update: maintaining the "Overweight" rating and US$400 price target, but cutting EPS forecasts across all three fiscal years 2026, 2027, and 2028to US$14.98, US$15.85, and US$17.25 respectively, from prior values of US$15.03, US$16.09, and US$17.65.
Sales guidance raised, EPS guidance cut
The update directly corresponds to Home Depot, Inc.'s November 17 pre-market Q3 report and raised full-year guidance. Morgan Stanley sets its FY2026 picture in line with company framing: comparable sales growth of about 1.4%, adjusted operating margin of about 12.8%. Looking further out, its model lays out a gradual recovery path for FY2026/2027/2028 comparable sales growth of +1.4%/+2.6%/+3.5%, with operating margin first contracting then expandingcontracting about 23 basis points in 2026, then recovering 11 and 20 basis points in 2027 and 2028 respectively.
Worth noting is the contrary signal: Home Depot, Inc.'s quarterly results themselves beat expectationsQ3 sales of US$43.4 billion, up 4.9% year-over-year, above the roughly US$42.8 billion market expectation; comparable sales growth of 2.2%; adjusted EPS of US$3.86. The company also raised full-year total sales growth guidance to about 4.5%, at the top of the prior 2.5%4.5% range. But the guidance also shows full-year adjusted EPS growth of only about 2.0%below Morgan Stanley's prior earnings path. Gross margin pressure was cited as stemming from "product and M&A mix" (the consolidation impact of the SRS distribution business), partially offset by modest leverage in SG&A expenses. In other words, good news on the revenue side, bad news on the margin side, with the net effect being cuts to three-year EPS of roughly US$0.050.24 each.
Three scenarios: betting on a "cycle that will eventually come"
The headline content of the report is the pricing of three scenarios. Base case US$400, corresponding to about 22.5x FY2028 EPS of roughly US$17.25, or about 15.5x EV/EBITDAMorgan Stanley explicitly states the target multiple is above current valuation, on the grounds that Home Depot, Inc. is its "preferred cyclical stock" within coverage.
Bull case US$510 (about 24.5x): a healthy rebound in the home improvement market, driven by a recovery in existing home sales, Fed rate cuts, and higher GDP growth, with comparable sales growth rising to +2.0%/+5.1%/+5.5%, operating margin expanding 57 and 85 basis points in 2027 and 2028 respectively, and an EPS path of US$15.24/US$17.22/US$20.13.
Bear case US$265 (about 17.5x): the home improvement market fails to rebound across all three fiscal years 20262028existing home sales recovery fails, mortgage rates stay elevated, and post-pandemic wallet share continues to shift away from the home improvement category. Under this scenario, EPS stays flat at US$14.7714.89 over three years, operating margin contracts year after year, and EBIT growth is near zero or even turns negative.
The Overweight thesis itself is unchanged: strong execution, a differentiated Pro customer ecosystem, and continued investment in stores, digital, and the distribution network; Morgan Stanley expects share gains to support near-term comparable sales, and "when existing home sales eventually recover, Home Depot, Inc. is the best beneficiary." In the report's driver framework, the core variables for comparable sales are grouped into threehome price appreciation, existing home sales, and homeownership ratewhile margin expansion depends on the company's "responsible expense management." Its quantitative model ranks Home Depot, Inc. as the 4th/5th best name in a five-quintile ranking on a 24-month horizon (5 being least favored), but only 2/5 on a 3-month horizonthe combination of a weak short-term ranking and a favorable long-term view precisely explains why this update chose to reiterate rather than add.
Worth noting is the industry reference frame: among U.S. peers also in Morgan Stanley's hardline retail coverage, Lowe's Companies, Inc. (LOW.US) is likewise rated Overweightthe two home improvement giants share the same "cyclical recovery option" logic in its framework, with Home Depot, Inc.'s differentiated edge being the depth of its Pro ecosystem. On positioning structure, active managers account for 50.6% of institutional holdings, the hedge fund sector long/short ratio is 1.8x with net exposure of 10.4%crowding is not particularly high, leaving room to add if the recovery trade kicks off.
Market pricing and earnings backdrop
Options market risk-neutral probabilities (as of November 17): about 26.9% chance the stock touches above US$400 within 12 months, about 19.5% chance it falls below US$265, and only about 4.8% chance it reaches US$510options pricing acknowledges upside exists but has limited confidence in the bull case materializing. Under Refinitiv, the consensus target price distribution ranges from US$255425, with ratings at 58% Overweight, 39% Neutral, 3% UnderweightMorgan Stanley's US$400 sits near the upper end of the consensus range.
The earnings report itself also contains a governance variable: Home Depot, Inc. announced the same day that CFO Richard McPhail will succeed as CEO on November 23, replacing Ted Decker, who has been on medical leave since August and has now returned but is stepping down (remaining as board chairman), with Jordan Broggi becoming CFO and Ann-Marie Campbell serving as President and COO. Management succession combined with raised guidance shows the company chose to proactively release certainty during the transition window. The structure of the Q3 report also corroborates Morgan Stanley's Pro narrative: comparable average ticket up 3.0%, comparable transactions down 0.5%, with professional contractor demand offsetting soft DIY consumption; online comparable sales up about 13%, maintaining double-digit growth for the sixth consecutive quarter.
The most accurate reading of this report is: Morgan Stanley did not change its stance over the modest downward revisions to the quarterly report, but rather treats Home Depot, Inc. as an option ticket on "falling rates + recovering existing home turnover"the EPS cuts are the premium, and the cyclical recovery is the payout.
Related Articles

HK Stock Market Move | PHANCY (06682) rose nearly 4% in the afternoon; the company officially released two open-source models in the Phai series.

Citi: Raises MNSO (09896) target price to HK$22.6, maintains "Neutral" rating

Morgan Stanley: Raises STANCHART (02888) target price to HK$265, maintains "Overweight" rating
HK Stock Market Move | PHANCY (06682) rose nearly 4% in the afternoon; the company officially released two open-source models in the Phai series.

Citi: Raises MNSO (09896) target price to HK$22.6, maintains "Neutral" rating

Morgan Stanley: Raises STANCHART (02888) target price to HK$265, maintains "Overweight" rating






