Starship's successful recovery fails to boost the stock price! Morgan Stanley: Market is reassessing SpaceX's (SPCX.US) business model and strategic risks, maintains $300 price target.
Morgan Stanley believes investors are currently more focused on the uncertainties surrounding SpaceX in AI infrastructure, its business model, and its collaboration with Tesla, rather than the upside from a single space technology breakthrough.
Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas noted in a research report released on November 16 that although SpaceX's (SPCX.US) 15th Starship test flight achieved a major breakthrough with the successful completion of a historic spacecraft recovery, the capital market reacted tepidly. The firm believes investors are currently more focused on uncertainties surrounding SpaceX's AI infrastructure, business model, and collaboration with Tesla, Inc. (TSLA.US) rather than the upside from a single space technology breakthrough.
However, Morgan Stanley remains bullish on SpaceX's long-term prospects, maintaining its "Overweight" rating and $300 price target. Compared with the closing price of $137.36 on November 16, the target price implies potential upside of about 118%.
**Starship Achieves Historic Breakthrough, Why Is the Market Reacting Coldly?**
Morgan Stanley noted that SpaceX's Starship test flight was an important milestone in spaceflight history, but investor attention was unexpectedly low. The firm said that despite many noteworthy events in the market recently, on the day Starship completed its major technical breakthrough, the number of investors proactively contacting analysts about SpaceX fell to one of its lowest levels in weeks.
The firm believes this does not mean investors have stopped paying attention to SpaceX, but rather that the market is reassessing its business model and strategic risks.
Specifically, SpaceX is gradually transforming from a traditional aerospace company into an AI infrastructure operator, with businesses involving new areas such as AI computing power, cloud computing, and data center construction. Although these businesses have significant growth potential, they also carry risks such as a business model that has not yet been fully validated and high customer concentration.
At the same time, potential further cooperation between SpaceX and Tesla, Inc. has also become a focus for investors. Morgan Stanley noted that even though some investors are optimistic about the prospects for deeper cooperation between the two companies, concerns about possible future equity dilution still make them unwilling to further increase their investment exposure to SpaceX at this stage.
**SpaceX's Valuation Appeal Stands Out, 2028 P/E May Be Only 17.5x**
Despite increasingly cautious market sentiment, Morgan Stanley believes SpaceX's current share price already offers strong valuation appeal. As of November 16, SpaceX's share price was $137.36, only about 1.7% above its IPO price of $135. Meanwhile, since early July this year, Morgan Stanley has raised its 2027 and 2028 earnings per share forecasts for SpaceX by 80% and 60%, respectively.
According to the firm's latest forecasts, SpaceX's earnings per share are expected to be $0.58, $3.95, and $9.91 in 2026, 2027, and 2028, respectively.
Morgan Stanley noted that based on its 2028 earnings forecast and excluding the impact of related tax benefits, SpaceX currently trades at about 17.5x its expected 2028 earnings.
This valuation is based on relatively prudent assumptions for AI computing power expansion. The firm expects SpaceX's computing power scale to reach 8.3 gigawatts (GW) by the end of 2027, below Musk's target of 13 GW, and to further increase to 14 GW by the end of 2028.
In addition, the firm expects SpaceX's revenue per unit of computing power to gradually decline from $34 per watt in the first quarter of 2027 to $21 per watt for full-year 2028.
If using the Visible Alpha consensus earnings estimates and also excluding the impact of related tax benefits, SpaceX currently trades at only about 11.2x its expected 2028 earnings, below Morgan Stanley's forecast of 16.2x for the S&P 500 over the same period.
Morgan Stanley believes this means the market has not yet fully reflected SpaceX's future earnings growth potential.
**AI, Siasun Robot&Automation, and Tesla, Inc. Synergies May Become the Next Growth Driver**
In addition to its space business, Morgan Stanley also emphasized that SpaceX's long-term investment value may come more from the deep integration of artificial intelligence, Siasun Robot&Automation, and the real economy.
The firm believes that Musk's and SpaceX's ultimate goal is not simply to build a leading new cloud computing company, nor merely to develop large language models or chat Siasun Robot&Automation, but to build an intelligent system network driven by AI that can execute tasks in the real world.
SpaceX's advantages in global communications networks, space infrastructure, and AI computing power, combined with Tesla, Inc.'s capabilities in autonomous driving, Siasun Robot&Automation, and large-scale manufacturing, may provide an important foundation for this strategy.
Morgan Stanley gave an example: if 1 million Siasun Robot&Automation were deployed in Austin, Texas, in the future, with each Siasun Robot&Automation having an average of 1 kilowatt of computing power, these interconnected Siasun Robot&Automation would form a distributed computing network with a total scale of 1 GW. If scaled further to 10 GW, the potential application space would be even broader.
The firm believes this model of distributing computing power throughout the real world may drive artificial intelligence to expand further from digital applications into the real economy.
At the same time, Morgan Stanley also suggested that the future direction of AI may gradually shift from replacing human jobs to creating new employment opportunities. The firm expects that as intelligent Siasun Robot&Automation and related infrastructure become more widespread, the link between AI and household income growth and overall economic prosperity may become closer, potentially creating millions of new jobs over the long term.
**Potential Cooperation Between Musk and Former NVIDIA Corporation CEO Jensen Huang Draws Attention**
Morgan Stanley also mentioned possible cooperation between Musk and Jensen Huang, former chief executive officer of NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA.US).
The research report noted that Musk said on social platform X last week that it would be an "honor" to be able to recruit Huang to the team. Morgan Stanley believes this statement deserves investor attention and raised the question of what impact Huang's hypothetical joining of SpaceX might have on the company's share price. However, the report did not claim that the two sides had reached any cooperation or employment agreement.
On the manufacturing side, Tesla, Inc. announced on Monday that it would invest an additional EUR3 billion in its Berlin Gigafactory in Germany to support expanding production of the Cybercab autonomous vehicle through 2029.
Morgan Stanley noted that against the backdrop of traditional automakers announcing layoffs and some companies planning to cut tens of thousands of jobs, Tesla, Inc.'s move to expand manufacturing investment stands in sharp contrast.
In addition, regarding Musk's vision for large-scale semiconductor manufacturing, Morgan Stanley believes that if the relevant plans truly advance to an ultra-large scale, investors may need to watch the development of new manufacturing technologies such as free electron lasers (FEL), not just the currently widely used extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography technology.
**Starship Recovery Technology May Intensify Industry Competition; Falcon 9 Technology Licensing Unlikely**
On the space business side, Morgan Stanley believes that after the successful 15th Starship test flight, other aerospace companies may further accelerate development of reusable rocket technology. The firm expects other U.S. aerospace companies and overseas competitors may increase investment in reusable launch systems, thereby driving technological competition across the space industry.
However, on whether SpaceX might license its Falcon 9 rocket launch architecture to other companies, Morgan Stanley gave a clear negative judgment. The firm believes SpaceX has no incentive to provide its mature core launch technology to competitors, and other companies will still need to independently develop their own rocket systems.
Morgan Stanley emphasized that investors should understand SpaceX's development strategy from a longer-term perspective. Just as launching satellites for other companies in its early days was not its ultimate goal, but rather a way to accumulate capital and technical experience for a grander space business, its current push into AI computing power and cloud computing may also be just an important step toward realizing a future intelligent real economy.
According to Morgan Stanley's sum-of-the-parts valuation model, of its $300 price target for SpaceX, the space business contributes $8, the communications business contributes $111, the X and Grok business contributes $11, and the enterprise AI business contributes $170.
The firm noted that factors that could further drive SpaceX's valuation higher in the future include faster progress in Starship reusability, growth in Starlink network capacity, expansion of the enterprise AI business, and falling costs of computing power infrastructure construction.
However, potential risks should not be ignored, including Starship reusability progress falling short of expectations, slower Starlink user growth, weak enterprise AI commercialization performance, rising capital expenditures, and equity dilution caused by increased future financing needs.
Related Articles

CITIC SEC: Cost reduction and profit growth; the economic inflection point for domestic standalone energy storage is approaching.

FIN STREET SEC (01476): Chairman Zhu Yanhui is under investigation and subject to retention measures

China Securities Co.,Ltd.: AI advanced packaging drives upgrading of glass substrate materials; equipment takes the lead in the early stage of industrialization.
CITIC SEC: Cost reduction and profit growth; the economic inflection point for domestic standalone energy storage is approaching.

FIN STREET SEC (01476): Chairman Zhu Yanhui is under investigation and subject to retention measures

China Securities Co.,Ltd.: AI advanced packaging drives upgrading of glass substrate materials; equipment takes the lead in the early stage of industrialization.






