Raw material shortages weigh on magnet production; USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) downgraded by William Blair as critical minerals sector weakens in tandem.
William Blair downgraded USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) from "Outperform" to "Market Perform."
William Blair downgraded USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) from "Outperform" to "Market Perform" with no price target, citing a series of near-term challenges, including a recent raw material shortage that is slowing rare earth magnet production, even though the company "is laying the groundwork for significant upside in the future." USA Rare Earth shares plunged 12.62% on Monday.
William Blair analyst Neal Dingmann said that given the raw material shortage will continue to affect subsidiary Less Common Metals and in turn the Stillwater magnet plant, he has pushed out USA Rare Earth's sales and margin estimates significantly to 2028.
Dingmann noted that the Serra Verde project will eventually help alleviate the raw material shortage, but under a 15-year take-or-pay offtake agreement, 100% of the project's Phase 1 output has already been committed to SIIE. SIIE is a Pentagon-backed, U.S. government-funded special purpose vehicle aimed at reducing America's dependence on foreign sources of critical minerals. Meanwhile, the raw material support that the Round Top project could potentially provide will still take years to materialize.
In addition, other business segments face operational challenges as they ramp up, and the rare earth segment also carries headline risk. "As such, near term we prefer companies with longer histories of material processing," Dingmann wrote.
The downgrade appeared to spill over into other critical minerals stocks. Critical Metals (CRML.US) fell 14%, MP Materials (MP.US) fell 6.9%, Rare Earth Americas (REA.US) fell 18.9%, Albemarle (ALB.US) fell 5.7%, Sociedad Quimica y Minera de Chile S.A. Sponsored ADR Pfd Series B (SQM.US) fell 4.6%, Lithium Americas (LAC.US) fell 5.3%, Argentina Lithium (LAR.US) fell 5.4%, Standard Lithium (SLI.US) fell 4.4%, Sigma Lithium (SGML.US) fell 12.2%, Atlas Lithium (ATLX.US) fell 5.2%, American Battery Technology (ABAT.US) fell 9.3%, and United States Antimony Corporation (UAMY.US) fell 13.6%.
Related Articles
CICC: Maintains CTHK (06055) target price of HK$30 and "Outperform" rating.

A-share Pre-market Briefing | Philadelphia Semiconductor Index Falls Over 5%, Ammonium Chloride Rises 12.5%, Automakers' Payment Terms Rectification

GMTEight List of A-share restricted sales and lifting restrictions | November 17
CICC: Maintains CTHK (06055) target price of HK$30 and "Outperform" rating.
A-share Pre-market Briefing | Philadelphia Semiconductor Index Falls Over 5%, Ammonium Chloride Rises 12.5%, Automakers' Payment Terms Rectification

GMTEight List of A-share restricted sales and lifting restrictions | November 17






